Location: Key West, FL
Captain: Garrett Frey
Vessel: 29' Sea Vee Center Console
Specialization: Bottom fishing, reef/wreck fishing, offshore trolling, shark fishing
Why ALL IN Stands Out
Here's something you don't see often in the charter business: Captain Garrett Frey runs ALL IN Fishing Charters with a "no fish, no pay" guarantee. That's right - if you don't catch fish, you don't pay. After researching dozens of Key West charters, I've found this policy is extremely rare, and it tells you everything about his confidence in putting clients on fish.
What makes this even more credible is Garrett's background. This isn't someone who bought a boat and hung out a shingle. He started fishing at age two in Indiana, moved to Key West after high school, and earned an Associate of Science degree in Marine Engineering from Florida Keys Community College (source: guide's official website). He then spent 6.5 years working as first mate and captain on the Second Nature before launching his own operation. That's 14+ years specializing in bottom fishing for snappers, groupers, and sharks.
The results speak for themselves: ALL IN holds a perfect 5.0/5 rating on FishingBooker based on 10 reviews, with consistent five-star feedback across TripAdvisor and other platforms. I couldn't find a single negative review across any platform - and I looked (sources: FishingBooker, TripAdvisor).
The Vessel: The ALL IN
Captain Garrett runs a 29-foot Sea Vee center console powered by a 300 HP Volvo Penta engine. According to his website and customer reviews, the boat has been fully renovated and is kept spotless. Multiple reviewers specifically mentioned the boat's excellent condition.
Amenities:
- •RV toilet onboard
- •Ice and water provided
- •Maximum capacity of 6 passengers
- •All fishing gear and bait included
One reviewer described it as "spotless," and the Marine Engineering background shows in how well-maintained the vessel is (source: customer reviews on FishingBooker and TripAdvisor).
What to Expect on a Trip
Trip Options & Transparent Pricing
ALL IN offers flat-rate pricing regardless of whether you bring 1 person or 6 - a nice advantage for families or larger groups. Here's what's available (pricing verified via official website):
- •Half Day (4 hours): $900 flat rate - Nearshore fishing
- •Three-Quarter Day (6 hours): $1,100 flat rate - Nearshore/offshore fishing
- •Full Day (8 hours): $1,400 flat rate - Nearshore/offshore fishing
Shark fishing trips are available in 3-, 4-, or 6-hour options, though specific pricing for these specialty trips isn't listed on the website. Tarpon fishing is also offered seasonally, with pricing available upon request.
Captain Garrett's website explicitly states there are "no hidden fees," and payment is accepted via cash, credit card, or PayPal. We couldn't verify the specific cancellation policy, so it's worth asking when you book.
What's Included
- •All fishing gear and tackle
- •Bait and ice
- •Water
- •Complete fish cleaning and filleting service
One customer wrote: "Cleaned, filleted and deboned every one of our fish" (source: TripAdvisor review). This is a significant value-add - professional filleting service can easily run $50+ at local shops.
What's NOT Included
- •Florida fishing license (required - bring your own)
- •Gratuity for the captain
- •Food and drinks beyond water
Target Species
Captain Garrett runs a versatile operation covering multiple fishing styles. Based on his website and customer catch reports, you can target:
Bottom/Reef Species:
- •Mutton Snapper
- •Yellowtail Snapper
- •Mangrove Snapper
- •Red Snapper
- •Cubera Snapper
- •Black Grouper
- •Goliath Grouper (catch-and-release)
- •Amberjack
Offshore Species:
- •Mahi-Mahi
- •King Mackerel
- •Wahoo
- •Sailfish
- •Barracuda
Specialty Targets:
- •Sharks (Sharp Nose, Sandbar, various species)
- •Tarpon (seasonal)
What Customers Are Saying
This is where ALL IN really shines. The pattern in reviews is remarkably consistent: people catch a lot of fish, kids have a blast, and Captain Garrett knows exactly where to put you on productive spots.
Fishing Success
One group fishing a 4-hour trip reported catching "8 Mutton Snappers, 1 Red Snapper, 1 Cubera Snapper, 6 Sharp Nose Sharks & 3 Sandbar Sharks" (source: TripAdvisor review). That's serious production for half a day.
A tournament group wrote: "We caught nearly 40 fish and a dozen different species" and noted Captain Garrett was "professional, knowledgeable, and knew exactly where to put us on the best most producing spots" (source: FishingBooker review).
Another customer described it this way: "Put us on fish from the start and once we caught enough to eat, we switched it up for some larger species including a shark, amberjack and barracuda" (source: TripAdvisor review). That's the kind of adaptability you want in a captain - getting the cooler full, then targeting trophy fish.
Family-Friendly Operation
Multiple reviews mention kids specifically. One family wrote: "3 kids (8, 10 and 12) loved it and will never forget!" (source: TripAdvisor review).
Another said: "Captain Garrett was fun and very knowledgeable" and praised his patience with younger anglers (source: FishingBooker review).
Repeat Customers
The strongest endorsement is people coming back. I found multiple reviews from repeat customers: "Second trip with Captain Garrett," "We have never been disappointed fishing with Captain Garrett," and "Unbelievable experience every time" (sources: TripAdvisor and FishingBooker reviews).
When people are spending $900-$1,400 on a charter and they come back multiple times, that tells you something.
Practical Information
Location:
5950 Peninsular Ave, Slip 604
Key West, FL 33040
Contact:
Phone: (574) 238-8963
Email: Fishallincharters@gmail.com
Website: fishallinkeywest.com
Booking:
You can book directly through Captain Garrett's website, or through FishingBooker and Captain Experiences platforms.
Social Media:
Instagram: @fishallinkeywest (2,900+ followers with trip photos and recent catches)
Who This Charter Is Best For
Families with kids: The reviews make it clear Captain Garrett has patience with young anglers, and the flat-rate pricing means adding kids doesn't increase the cost. The consistent fish-catching also means kids won't get bored.
Serious anglers: If you're looking for someone who can put you on tournament-quality catches and knows the reef and wreck structure intimately, Garrett's 14 years specializing in bottom fishing delivers. One reviewer specifically mentioned using ALL IN for a tournament.
First-timers: The "no fish, no pay" guarantee takes the risk out of trying your first charter. Captain Garrett's reviews consistently mention his teaching and patience with beginners.
Groups looking for value: The flat-rate pricing for up to 6 people means larger groups get better per-person value than most charters that charge per angler.
Anyone who values transparency: Between the no-fish guarantee, flat pricing, and "no hidden fees" policy, you know exactly what you're getting into financially.
The Bottom Line
After reviewing ALL IN Fishing Charters thoroughly, a few things stand out: the no-fish-no-pay guarantee is genuinely rare and shows real confidence, Captain Garrett's Marine Engineering background and 14+ years of specialized experience translate to consistent catches, and the perfect review record across multiple platforms isn't an accident.
The thing about Key West is there are hundreds of charters to choose from. What separates the good ones from the great ones is whether the captain can consistently put you on fish, handle all experience levels, and run a professional operation. Based on the evidence - both from the guide's credentials and from actual customer experiences - ALL IN checks all those boxes.
If you're looking for a Key West charter that backs up its claims with a money-back guarantee and has the track record to support it, ALL IN Fishing Charters deserves serious consideration.
Book direct: fishallinkeywest.com
Phone: (574) 238-8963
Tight lines!
Profile based on research conducted January 22, 2026. Information verified through guide's official website, FishingBooker reviews, TripAdvisor reviews, and other publicly available sources. Pricing and availability subject to change - confirm directly with captain when booking.
